Plato v/s aristotle
Answer 1:
First of all plato was basically philosopher so he deals with psychophysical ideas and states that
"Truth of philosophy was more importance than pleasure poetry"
as a moral list he believed that literature should be righteous, intelligence, and achieve a perfect state. He Argued that too good poet compose well unless he knows his subject. Which must have knowledge of the original while he copy or imitation of literary work. It should imitate correctly. His objection is open viewed as portraying either " male dominance" or " female exploitation " for that instance one television serial name "Udaan" which telecast in 1989. It is a story about inspiring female IPS officer. In comparison of recent television serial" Diya aur baati hum" IPS officer Sandhya present current situation ok today's female, they still wearing "saree with pallu" also struggling for his academical value as well as identity. Other one is "saath nibhaana saathiya" presents a concept of angry mother in law "Gopi vahu" still busy in household works also ethnic outfits again " pallu" .
The most popular and also banned television serials "Balika vadhu" it shows the fight against child marriages, missing out school events. Which is located in rural Rajasthan. Sexual assault and teen pregnancy are the real problem shown in that.
When plato talk about male dominance a very appropriate example of serials named "pehredar piya ki" which was recently banned. Social issue played his role that " 10 years old very little kids caressing stalking a lady who is is more than double his age and the most controversial element is that he is feeling sindoor in her maang"
Plato states that children grow to be good moral individuals a good truthful for literature . That kinds of frenzy to kill children.As per Plato literature should be fruitful and useful too. But recently banned a very antisocial object such as "PUBG GAME" "BLUE WHALE" as per ' 'business news today' that games associated with violence behaviour and low academic grades of students as per business today news 18064 accounts banned permanently. Under the guise of freedom of speech people are using app like "TIKTOK" to spread fake news and malicious content.
Plato states that copy or imitate correctly and at least aware about original "The face of mother India" by Katherine Mayo as per Wikipedia The mother India is a polemical book by American historian and Katherine Mayo sweet attacks Indian society religion and culture to
Answer 2:
The concept of tragedy is that rests upon the assertion of universal moral order. The Fall of the hero momentarily disturbs that order.
The term " tregic hero" is comes from Greek. Aristotle says that tragic hero must be an intermediate kind of a person a man not permanently virtuous and just yet whose Miss Fortune is brought upon him not by vice or depravity but why some error of judgement.
The hero will mistakenly bring about his own downfall. "Othello" is the modern examples" odipus" in the ancient are to most conspicuous examples of ruin wrongly by character nobles indeed but not without defects.
The term " Hamartia" is a a department of man's blundering , which is committed against supernatural and it hence boneless in its import and consequences that we shall have to place hamartia of Greek tragedy " odipus" . The Hebrews tragedy character of " job" also the "paradise lost"
" Catharsis" was the Greek words means" purgation "related which human psychology this term established in tragedy just because of maintain a balance in drama. Sorrow alone would be ugly and repulsive. This term used as "metaphor" in politics by Aristotle to explain the impact of tragedy on the audience is the most prevalent exploration of characteristics purgation or cleansing.
William Shakespeare wrote to famous examples of catharsis. One of these example of tragic drama "Macbeth" audience and readers of MacBeth usually pity the tragic Central figure of the play because he was blinded by his destructive preoccupation with ambition .
Other one example is Romeo and Juliet are great lover. both commit suicide by drinking the poison . The primary element is the losing beloved one is a feeling that all of us haveexperienced.
Answer 3:
Tragedy appears in the night lead balanced and complete catered instance where a man of strong character and of eminent worldly position like Oedipus or thyestes suffers down full as a result of some others which we call hamartia and yet he is is under serving much like ourselves so we may experience fear and spectacle of his downfall.
The great writer of elizabethan period did not followed any Aristotle's rules of literaly tradition for instance " king Lear"is quite complex featuring a number of plots. King Lear breaks rule of unity of action. Other one is Romeo and Juliet place over several days instead of 24 hours it means it also break the rule of unity of time. Macbeth begins on a battlefield and has scenes in in Macbeth's Castle and England as also. Sweet bricks rule of unity of place.
Answer 4:
As per aristotelian literary tradition concept of tragedy " an imagination of an action that is serious complete and of a certain magnitude in a language embellished with each kind of acetic ornament the several kinds being found in a separate powers of the play in the form of action not of narratives throw pity and fear affecting the proper purgation (catharsis )of emotions'
The term" hamartia" etymologically this means the missing of a mark with bow and arrow and an skillful but not morally culpable act. According to one school of thought hamartia in Greek drama is is mainly e and spent upon a larger tragedy bof fate , mens largest suffering, unpredictable and without measure at the hands of God and man's stoic endurance.
Hamartia is a Latin word meaning of weakness of the hero or fatal Flow. As per Aristotle thought the hero enough to be good but not too good for instance Shakespeare's " " " Hamlet "is a such character: he is a good kind thoughts full gentle and cultivated he possesses all the heroine quality but has his own hamartia asphalt which is his "indecisive" power . Confused always in a state of to be or not to be"
When we talk about hamartia I would like to put some very interesting example of Bollywood movies like " Deevaar" the protagonist Vijay a man of action also with hamartia. Other one is" Darr" obsessed love by shahrukh Khan for Kiran. "Devdas" and " once upon a Time in Mumbai" last one is "sacred games"
So so this are the examples of hamartia and this examples firmly follwed tradition of Aristotelian theories.
Answer 5:
As per Aristotle theory " The Hairy app "follow the traditions of Aristotle .The protagonist was not a man of high rank he maintains the chain of incidents like working, injustice, exploitation, obsession, revenge as well as death of protagonist.
" Othello "kills his wife because he was not a man of high rank in him he is a blind lover of his wife, on the on the other hand you can see this there is a also place of the principle of probability because there is no need to kill Desdemona.
Well elaborated. Keep writing. 👌👌
ReplyDelete